This BBQ chicken grilled cheese became an instant favorite in my house the first time I tried it. I was cleaning out the fridge after a busy weekend and had a rotisserie chicken, a jar of BBQ sauce, and a loaf of thick Texas toast from a weekend grocery run. I tossed the shredded chicken with the sauce, layered it between generous amounts of cheddar and mozzarella, and cooked the sandwiches until the bread was golden and the cheese flowed. The resulting sandwich was smoky, sweet, and deeply satisfying—rich pockets of cheese, tender chicken, and the crisp, buttery crust that only thick-sliced bread can deliver. From that moment on, these sandwiches became my go-to for quick weeknight dinners and casual game-day feeding.

What makes this version special is the balance of textures and flavors. The shredded chicken soaks up the BBQ sauce and stays juicy, while two types of cheese create both melt and stretch. Using thick Texas toast or the thick French bread from Costco ensures the sandwich holds everything together and develops a crunchy exterior without collapsing. This recipe is messy in the best possible way; it begs for extra napkins and a cold drink. I first cooked it on a cast-iron griddle, and watching the cheese bubble through the sides while the bread formed a deep golden crust is one of my favorite simple cooking pleasures.

Ingredients

• Shredded chicken (3 cups): Rotisserie chicken works best for convenience and flavor; pull warm meat off the bones and shred with forks for the ideal texture.
• BBQ sauce (1/2 cup): I used Sweet Baby Ray's for its balanced sweet and tangy profile; substitute your favorite brand or homemade sauce for a different flavor.
• Texas toast (8 slices): Thick-sliced bread is essential to hold the filling and develop a crunchy exterior; supermarket Texas toast or a thick-cut French loaf are both excellent.
• Butter (6 tablespoons): Softened and spread on the outsides of each slice to ensure even browning; salted butter adds depth, but unsalted lets you control sodium.
• Shredded cheese (3 to 4 cups): A blend of sharp cheddar and a melty cheese like mozzarella gives both flavor and stretch; use more for extra gooeyness.
• Extra BBQ sauce: For drizzling before serving to amplify the sweet-tangy profile and add moisture to each bite.

Instructions

Combine the chicken and sauce: In a medium bowl, toss 3 cups shredded rotisserie chicken with 1/2 cup BBQ sauce until the meat is evenly coated. Taste and add a teaspoon more sauce if you prefer a saucier filling. Let the mixture rest 5 minutes to allow the sauce to meld with the chicken fibers. Prepare the bread: Spread softened butter on one side of each slice of Texas toast. The buttered side will contact the griddle; spread evenly to the edges to promote an even, golden crust. If your butter is cold, microwave for 5–8 seconds to soften but not melt. Assemble the sandwiches: Place a slice of bread butter side down on a preheated griddle or large skillet over medium heat. Layer a generous sprinkle of shredded cheddar, a scoop of the chicken mixture in the center, a light drizzle of extra BBQ sauce, and top with more shredded cheese. Finish with another slice of bread, butter side up. The double layer of cheese above and below the chicken ensures binding and a luxurious melt. Cook and flip: Cook over medium heat until the bottom is deeply golden and the cheese has begun to melt, about 3 to 5 minutes. Using a large spatula, carefully flip the sandwich and press gently to promote contact between bread and pan. Cook another 3 to 5 minutes until the second side is golden and the cheese is fully melted. If the bread browns too quickly before the cheese melts, lower the heat and cover the pan briefly for 30–60 seconds to trap heat. Serve: Remove from the pan and let rest 1 minute to set the filling, then slice in half. Drizzle with extra BBQ sauce and serve immediately with pickles or a side salad for contrast.

Storage Tips

To refrigerate, cool any leftover sandwiches to room temperature, wrap individually in plastic wrap or place in airtight containers, and refrigerate for up to three days. For longer storage, freeze wrapped sandwiches on a sheet tray until solid, then transfer to a freezer bag for up to two months. Reheat refrigerated sandwiches in a skillet over medium-low heat with a lid on for a few minutes per side to melt cheese while maintaining crunch. For frozen sandwiches, bake at 375°F for 12–18 minutes covered with foil, then uncover for 3–5 minutes to re-crisp the outside.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you do not have rotisserie chicken, poach or roast boneless skinless chicken breasts or thighs, then shred. For a vegetarian take, substitute pulled jackfruit tossed in BBQ sauce and use a dairy-free cheese alternative—note that texture will differ. Swap Sweet Baby Ray's for a spicy chipotle BBQ to add heat, or use an applewood-smoked sauce for deeper smokiness. If you prefer less richness, replace half the cheddar with reduced-fat cheese and use olive oil spread instead of butter on the bread, though the crust will be less decadent.

Serving Suggestions

Serve these sandwiches with crisp dill pickles, a sharp slaw, or a simple green salad dressed with a vinegar-forward dressing to cut through the richness. For a heartier meal, pair with baked fries or a cup of tomato basil soup for dunking. Garnish with chopped scallions for color and a squeeze of lemon if using spicy BBQ. When offering a sandwich bar, provide multiple BBQ sauce options and an array of cheeses so guests can customize their melt.

Cultural Background

This sandwich draws on two American comfort-food traditions: the classic grilled cheese and the barbecue pulled chicken sandwich. The grilled cheese evolved as a simple, satisfying meal across mid-century America, while pulled and shredded meats in BBQ sauce come from regional barbecue traditions across the South. Combining them creates a portable, hand-held hybrid that celebrates the gooey, toasty texture of the melt and the bold, tangy flavors of barbecue—both staples of casual American cooking.

Seasonal Adaptations

In summer, use fresh-picked jalapeños and grilled corn in the filling for brightness and crunch. In winter, swap in smoked gouda and a smoky chipotle BBQ for deeper, warming flavors. For fall gatherings, add caramelized onions and a handful of roasted apple cubes to echo harvest notes. Holidays offer the chance to make mini slider versions as appetizers—use Hawaiian rolls brushed with butter, which toasts beautifully and creates a sweet-savory bite-sized treat.

Meal Prep Tips

Prepare the shredded chicken and toss it with BBQ sauce up to three days ahead; keep refrigerated in an airtight container. Pre-shred your cheese and keep it in a sealed bag to make assembly fast. If packing for lunches, assemble the sandwich components separately—bread, chicken, and cheese—and quickly toast at work or home. Use disposable foil packets to grill multiple sandwiches on a camp stove or griddle for easy cleanup.

These sandwiches strike the rare balance of simplicity and indulgence. They're easy enough for a busy weeknight and special enough to share at casual gatherings. Try a small twist each time and keep notes—you might land on your family's new favorite variation.